February 2011 Employment Report

The much anticipated employment report for February was released this morning. The expectation was for an increase of about 200,000 jobs, while anticipated changes in the unemployment rate varied over a wide range. Here is a summary of the report, and a link to the CNBC video discussing it.

Today's market action illustrated an important concept  -- the whisper number. While there are official expectations (the market consensus), often the market has already priced this expectation in prior to the data release. The result: the market rises in anticipation of the number, but sells off when the expected number occurs. This is the basis of the old saying: "Buy on the rumor, sell on the news." Markets often do this. I prefer a re-wording of this: "Buy on the mystery, sell on the history." The whisper number is an unofficial number, representing what market participants actually want to occur for the market to move higher. Going into today, the expectation was +200,000 jobs, but the whisper number was much higher: +280,000 - +300,000. Since today's number was well below the whisper, hitting the consensus value was anticlimactic, so the market sold off. Note, however, that prior month values were revised higher as well, so this month's number was actually better than the 192,000 reported.

An hourly chart of the Dow-Jones Average helps to show this (click to enlarge). Note how the first four hourly candlesticks were bearish -- solid real bodies, indicating that the close for each hour was below the open. The fifth hour candle was a doji, touching the prior low. Recall that a doji indicates a "toss up" in terms of momentum. That candle actually marked a turning point, as the final two candles were bullish, with the first of these constituting a bullish engulfing pattern of the doji. The final candle of the day has a wider range and a large real body.

Throughout all of this, the Dow Jones remained in the uptrend that began late February (see dashed line). While today's price action erased much of yesterday's large gains, some of those gains remained.

Not all of today's Dow Jones action was related to the employment report, of course. There was a vary favorable factory orders number (+3.1%), the most rapid rise in years. Adding a seemingly more rapid trend in employment and the improving factory orders, oil prices rose sharply. The price per barrel of oil (West Texas Crude) closed the day at $104.91, an increase of almost 3 percent compared to yesterday.

So, while the talking heads appear all too willing to believe that the market won't be able to rise with oil above $100/barrel, the fact that the uptrend in the Dow Jones remains in tact, would appear to contradict them. What will it take for oil prices to rise dramatically? As I stated in class a while ago, dramatic reductions in either oil production or shipping in the middle east. This could happen. For now, the markets have not priced that risk in yet.

NASDAQ Support at the 50-Day Moving Average

The market has now been in correction mode for a few days now. Focusing on the NASDAQ, as of last Friday, the RSI was in overbought territory and a Doji appeared. Since then, the NASDAQ has been lower. But it is important to see that sometimes a "psychological level" can provide either support or resistance. In the present case, the 50-day moving average has become support for this NASDAQ's pullback, as the chart shows (click to enlarge).

Note how changes occurred right at the (rising) 50-day moving average. While the RSI remains below 50, the traditional value above which a bullish trend is viewed to be in place, it does still remain above 40 -- a level that can be viewed as support during an uptrend.

Does the uptrend remain in tact? Remember that an uptrend means higher highs and higher lows. At the present time, the recent lows remain above the low from the end of January, so the uptrend is still in force. Also, note the increase in the RSI over the past few days. This too provides some reason for optimism.

The fate of oil production and shipping in the Middle East will ultimately determine whether the present support level holds. However, the February employment number will be released on Friday morning (8:30am). This will be pivotal. A very bad number then absent weather influences, will very likely cause support to be broken -- for now.

November Employment Report

The November employment brought with it several surprises. First, and foremost, payroll employment fell by far less than just about anyone (including me) had predicted. While the consensus number was a decline of around 120,000, the actual number was a decline of just 11,000. In addition to this, decreases from the prior two months were revised to show less job loss. So, with the addition of Census workers early next year, it is very likely that we will see the employment change go positive -- either next month when the November data are revised or when we get January or February data.  Second, there was a nostalgic element to Friday's action in that the stock market actually rose along with the US dollar. When was the last time that happened? You should read about the employment report from MarketWatch.com and the Wall Street Journal.

The stock market liked the employment report very much. The Dow-Jones Average started out showing a gain of around 150, but as is so typical of employment release days, gave most of that back (this apparently works in both directions). At the end of the day, the Dow was up 23 points (for 0.2%). Interestingly, the NASDAQ was up by a greater percentage than the Dow, as its 21 point gain was almost 1 percent. Typically, when observing markets it is a good sign when the NASDAQ outperforms the Dow-Jones average. As this stock market "rally" was occurring, the bond market obviously hated what it saw, so a selloff resulted. As bond prices fell, the 10-year bond rate rose by a full 10 bp, a rather significant change. The US Dollar index rose by just over one point (1.07) to close at 75.8. So, enjoy this combination while you can -- a bullish report triggered stock market gains, a bond market sell off, a stronger US Dollar, and a drop in Gold price. That is the way things normally go, but haven't gone this semester as the result of the dollar carry trade.

Along with this favorable economic report, of course, comes all the myopic garbage that has come to characterize coverage by the financial media. Will the Fed now begin to raise rates very soon based on the new-found economic strength? Give me a break! Is the carry trade dead, based on Friday? Gee, we have one full day of that result, so it must be inevitable! I'll probably reserve judgment, though, until I hear from Jon and Kate, and check in with Tiger Woods. Here is the URL for an article with an intelligent discussion of the likelihood of Fed actions based on Friday's report.

The interesting question is how long the pattern of the inverse relationship between the dollar and US stock market has existed. It must seem to all of you that this has been around for a very long time, that this is the "norm." For extra credit due at the beginning of class on Tuesday, produce a chart using weekly data going back three years with the Dow-Jones average and the US Dollar index in the same chart, both as solid lines. Adding annotations, eliminating other elements of the graph like MA's, pinpoint when the current pattern began based on this chart.

So the question now becomes whether the dollar carry trade is dead or possibly dormant for a while. If this is conjecture turns out to be true, the US Dollar should begin to rally without threatening the positive momentum of the US stock market. We can use technical analysis along with economic theory to ascertain whether any short-term bottoming of the dollar is in the cards. Based on the RSI(9) from weekly data, there was a bullish divergence for $USD -- the RSI had been rising while the weekly $USD was recently falling. So, in the very short-term at least, some dollar strength is likely, especially since the RSI is nowhere near an overbought level. In fact, the weekly RSI(9) is at 40.5, which if you look back several months to April, is a resistance level for the RSI. If that resistance is broken, the dollar index could go to either 77 (its next resistance point  determined the usual way) or all the way to 80 based on a Fibbonnacci Retracement from March of 2009 until the most recent low. Stay tuned!

Friday's Employment Report

I had stated in class that the bond market anticipated a bad employment report. THE BOND MARKET WAS CORRECT. In anticipation of a larger-than-expected fall in employment (an actual fall of 263,000 -- much worse than the "consensus" estimate), and thus slower growth ahead, interest rates had been falling during this week. And, the actual number didn't do anything to reverse that trend. Here is a very short summary of the day's 10-year bond performance.


The chart (click to enlarge) shows the ten-year bond rate ($TNX). NOTE: the rate of interest is the listed value on the right axis divided by 10. So, 35 corresponds to a 3.5% rate, etc.  Resistance for the 10-year bond rate has recently been 3.5% -- you can see the rate bouncing off this level several times since August. Focusing only on this past week, we see a noticeable decline in the 10-year rate, in anticipation of a weak employment report.

As interest rates and bond prices are inversely related, note from the RSI indicator above the chart that rates are oversold, so a bond rally (on potentially bad news) has caused bond prices to be overbought.

There is one interesting thing about Friday after the employment release: the 10-year rate rose (and prices fell). And, while the rate hit 3.1% at one point during the day, the close was higher than the open. There was also a lower tail (remember: a possible signal of change of momentum). It is quite possible that the low on Friday may be a 10-year low for the short-term based on Friday's price bar. Keep in mind, though, that mortgage rates tend to be highly correlated with the 10-year bond rate, so it appears that we are going to see lower mortgage rates ahead (below 5% on 30-year mortgages). The real question is whether mortgage applications rise or fall ("other things" are not necessarily equal).

The stock market had a rough couple of days. After class on Thursday, the market dropped sharply. Friday, after the report, another sharp drop occurred until around mid-day when we came off the lows of the day. Here is a story about the stock and bond markets. For extra credit, due at the beginning of class on Tuesday, create a chart of the S&P 500 (daily) using "fill the chart" as the data range. Put the RSI in the same chart (not above or below it), paste this into a Word document. In that document, provide a brief summary indicating how the RSI signaled the recent stock market decline.

You should continue following the bond market throughout the remainder of this semester and beyond, noting what it is forecasting and contrast this with what the stock market is assuming. We will cover the stock market this week.

Does This Rally Have Legs?

Friday, after a horrible employment report, the market actually rose significantly. Is the market discounting that the worst is now behind us? Or, did the terrible jobs report signal the necessity of both bailing out the "Big 3" automakers and that President-Elect Obama will have to provide an extremely large stimulus package? I think it is far more the latter. Here is a ShortView by John Authers of the Financial Times discussing the current state of the markets.

How far will the market go? In the short-term, you should always check to see where resistance is. In the chart below of the Dow-Jones average (click to enlarge), note the market ended the day just at its 50-day moving average. More importantly, it is instructive to check the Fibonacci Retracement tool I discussed in class just before Thanksgiving. This is included in the graph.

To add a Fibonacci Retracement, go to the Annotation screen (click below the image to get this). When the Java window appears, click on the Fibonacci Tool as shown in the upper portion of the graph.

Holding the left mouse key down, drag the mouse sideways and down:
(1) From the most recent significant high, to
(2) The most recent low. Once there, release the mouse key.

Note how the most likely place for a resistance point, the 38.2% retracement (the first line) is essentially where the market is now approaching. Is it likely that the Dow-Jones will reach this? Check the RSI. It is above 50 (indicating the beginning of a possible uptrend) and it is not close to being overbought. So the potential is clearly there. Also, check to see if there are any major economic statistics this week that if bad could derail this uptrend. There is nothing on the horizon like the employment report of last Friday. So, it is reasonable for the market to move past its 50-day moving average and test the 38.2% retracement at 9,164.

There may well be a "Santa Claus" rally as this year comes to an end, as the bailout (part 1) and promise of an extensive stimulus package will act like the "rumor" in the old saying buy on the rumor, sell on the news. So, early next year, there may well be some kind of correction. But, the relevant question is from what level will this correction occur? We'll have to wait until next semester.