NASDAQ Support at the 50-Day Moving Average

The market has now been in correction mode for a few days now. Focusing on the NASDAQ, as of last Friday, the RSI was in overbought territory and a Doji appeared. Since then, the NASDAQ has been lower. But it is important to see that sometimes a "psychological level" can provide either support or resistance. In the present case, the 50-day moving average has become support for this NASDAQ's pullback, as the chart shows (click to enlarge).

Note how changes occurred right at the (rising) 50-day moving average. While the RSI remains below 50, the traditional value above which a bullish trend is viewed to be in place, it does still remain above 40 -- a level that can be viewed as support during an uptrend.

Does the uptrend remain in tact? Remember that an uptrend means higher highs and higher lows. At the present time, the recent lows remain above the low from the end of January, so the uptrend is still in force. Also, note the increase in the RSI over the past few days. This too provides some reason for optimism.

The fate of oil production and shipping in the Middle East will ultimately determine whether the present support level holds. However, the February employment number will be released on Friday morning (8:30am). This will be pivotal. A very bad number then absent weather influences, will very likely cause support to be broken -- for now.

The 50-Day Moving Average as Support

In the last post, I addressed how the Dow-Jones Industrial Average (DJIA) failed at resistance. In cases where the DJIA is expected to fall from that level, how far can it be expected to decline? To translate this into technical analysis terms, where is the next support level? In the most recent situation, that support was at the 50-day moving average. The chart below shows this (click to enlarge).

Notice how the market moved all the way down to the 50-day moving average then "bounced" off this newly found support level. As of the time this post is being written the Dow is moving once again toward the prior resistance level.

Had the market fallen below its support at the 50-day moving average, where would it likely have fallen? Again, where are the next support levels? We should view the 50-day moving average as support level #1 (S1). Below that, the next support (S2) occurs around 10,900, then 10,700 is S3 (both of these are derived from horizontal support lines. After S3 comes the 200-day moving average at 10,600. Note, though, that the DJIA moved above support here when it was not yet overbought (the RSI never fell below 30). So, it is quite possible that we will be testing resistance once again. As I have stated in earlier posts, to determine whether resistance is likely to hold, it is necessary to evaluate what would drive profit expectations to higher levels so that resistance would be broken? Again, check the economic calendar for the upcoming week or two.

Let me finish this post by showing another way to determine likely levels of support should the market fall in coming days. This is illustrated using Fibonacci Analysis. In StockCharts.com, when you choose "Annotation," there is an icon to do this. Go from the most recent low to the recent high. The result is illustrated below (click to enlarge).

To add Fibonacci Analysis, click on the button highlighted in the upper portion of the above chart, then drag your mouse from the low value to the high (hold the mouse button until you reach the final level).

According to Fibonacci Analysis, the first likely level of support from an uptrend "retraces" 38.2% of that uptrend (this is called a Fibonacci Retracement). If that level of support fails, the next likely support occurs at 50% retracement. Finally, the last support level is at 61.8% retracement. If the market falls below 61.8% retracement, it is fairly likely that the prior low will be tested. Consult the RSI to assist you in deciding (in real time) if this is likely to occur.

Three Different Resistance Measures

The S&P 500 has stalled around its 50-day moving average, as was true the other day (see the previous post). Now that a few more days have passed since then, we saw a couple of spinning tops, which indicate indecision, then a large down day (yesterday) followed by a significant up day (today). Today's bullish candlestick was not as large as yesterday's bearish candle, and today the market opened from a higher level than yesterday's close. In OHLC charting, this is referred to as an inside day. Overall, I think it is safe to say that there is no definitive direction for future price change at this time. As I stated in class, at times like this, it is advisable to consult the economic calendar for the remainder of this week and next week, identify the "biggie" releases that will occur, then attempt to determine what each of these will do and how the market will react. Nobody can know this with certainty, so don't be intimidated. Actually, if you listen to the "talking heads" on the financial stations and keep track of what they predict, you'll probably be surprised by how inaccurate these persons are. So, don't be afraid to venture out and try this, you probably won't do any worse than the "talking heads."

Look at the following charts and analyze the most recent candlesticks and think about what they indicate about the battle between bulls and bears. Using these, I will now present three different ways to measure resistance.

#1: Fibonacci Retracement: If we apply a Fibonacci Retracement to the most recent high and low of the daily S&P 500 (see chart, click to enlarge), we see something quite interesting: the recent rally stalled at the 61.8% retracement point. The use of Fibonacci Retracement suggests that after a decline, the first possible point of resistance in a rally is when 38.2% of that rally has been erased (retraced). The next possible resistance point is at 50%, while the last occurs at 61.8% retracement.

#2: 50-day Moving Average: The next charts (click to enlarge) shows that the 50-day moving average acted as support for the S&P 500 since last fall, then became resistance in late January of this year. It is fairly common for prior support to become resistance (and vice versa). Note how the most recent rally failed just at the 50-day moving average. At this point, based on the most recent candlesticks, the direction of future price is still a toss up. A definitive move above the 50-day moving average, especially for a major market index, would be very bullish, and we might have a shot at returning to the previous high. If that were to occur, then the market falls below that level, what technical formation do we have? A double top, which is a reversal pattern. More about establishing a down target later this semester if this possibility occurs.

#3: RSI(9) < 60. In this same chart, look at the RSI in the upper portion. Note how the most recent high coincided with the RSI falling below 60 and remaining there. Just as the S&P is now testing its 50-day moving average, so too is it testing the RSI at 60.Often, an RSI value of 60 is used as resistance for a downtrend, while 40 is used to designate support for an uptrend.

So, what will happen from here? As I stated above, look at the economic calendar, identify the "biggie" numbers that can potentially move the market, and attempt to predict what each of these will do. In doing this, you are actually using economic theory, which states (for our purposes at this point):

      Stock Prices = f(interest rates, expected future profit)

In analyzing the future releases, focus primarily on the macroeconomic implications for profit expectations, since Fed Chair Bernanke indicated again today that the fed funds rate will remain low "for the foreseeable future." That reassurance was a fundamental driver of today's rally which erased most of yesterday's losses.

Surprise Discount Rate Announcment

Yesterday, after the markets closed, the Fed announced that it was raising the discount rate by 25 bp. Here is a story about this. The initial reaction after hours was as expected -- the announcement took everyone by surprise. Before this morning's market open, futures pointed to a down day, although the amount kept shrinking. What all of this points to is uncertainty and indecision as market participants digested all of this and formulated their views of the likely consequences.

Which types of candlestick bars depict this? Forget a candle with a long real body and little in terms of shadows (i.e., tails). Look over the candlesticks I covered the other day in class. One would expect either a doji or a spinning top. What actually occurred for the S&P 500 was a spinning top. Here is a chart of the current data (click to enlarge) as of the Friday close.

The RSI is not yet overbought, so potentially there is room for further upward price movement. Note that the RSI is approximately 60, which is the value that some use to indicate resistance for a time of weak price movement. The most striking thing in this chart is the fact that the $SPX closed above its 50-day MA for the first time since January of this  year. If the market were worried about the impact of the Fed raising the discount rate, would the S&P have closed above its 50-day MA today? No, it would not have. So, today's price action, in spite of signaling indecision in terms of a spinning top, does allow for the possibility that it the S&P will remain above its 50-day MA at least for the very near term. The real question is whether former resistance, in terms of the 50-day MA, will now become support.

How can we arrive at a way to answer this question? Using economic theory, we model stock prices. According to economic theory:

                    Stock Price = f(interest rates, expected profits)

Interest rates pertain to asset substitution possibilities in the short-term (review the stock and bond info in the Supply and Demand notes) and product demand in the medium term. Were yesterday's surprise discount rate announcement taken to indicate that Fed tightening was about to begin, not only would the market have failed to clear the 50-day MA today, there would likely have been a noticeable upper shadow (tail) as well. Also, there was a CPI data report today that signaled benign inflation, which signals that interest rates should not rise much.  So, the primary factor to focus on is profit expectations. For extra credit, due at the beginning of class on Tuesday, plot the relative strength of the S&P 500 (a measure of stocks) compared to TLT, a measure of longer-term bond prices using as a chart type a solid line with weekly data. In a short word document, include the chart with annotations from StockCharts.com (not hand written) and a very short discussion of what the relative strength of stocks vs bonds is showing us about expectations for future economic activity (and therefore profits). Feel free to consult John Murphy's text about this.

When you get a chance, you should read two excellent columns on technical analysis by Michael Kahn in Barron's Online. I strongly suggest that you save these and others throughout this semester (and beyond). The first of these, written in early February, talks about the market correction. Follow his reading of candlestick charts and overall analysis. The second, from this past week, analyzes the question of whether the market will be fighting back and trend up.

Gaps and the NASDAQ

On occasion, gaps appear in price charts. These arise almost exclusively in daily and intra-day charts. There are a number of things that cause gaps to emerge in individual stocks, such as news or earnings announcements (positive or negative) coming out after a day's trading has ended, which causes a new equilibrium price that is different enough to gap up or down from the prior day's trading range. Actually, there are several different types of gaps. There is a good article about them at Chart School in StockCharts.com, and another about how to trade gaps on Investopdia.

The reason for this blog post is that the NASDAQ has seen several gaps over the past few weeks. The chart below (click to enlarge) shows this. One thing that many of us who follow the market utilize is the tendency for gaps to be filled. How long it takes for this to occur, however, can vary widely, and it depends on the type of gap (see the articles above). Some, breakaway gaps, for example, can take quite a while to fill, if they even end up being filled. At the other extreme is exhaustion gaps, which are very likely to fill (see articles). The gaps in the NASDAQ chart are merely "plain vanilla" or standard gaps. Note an interesting pattern for the last two gaps: they both filled on the third day (almost sounds biblical!). DO NOT make anything of this, it is merely a coincidence.

I do want to point out a trading strategy related to the typical gap. Since gaps tend to eventually fill (again, depending on the type), some traders will essentially place trades that presuppose this. In other words, they trade in the opposite direction of the gap. This is called fading the gap. While I have used this on a number of occasions in the past, I did so with added criteria. So, according to this trading philosophy, if a down gap emerges, go long in anticipation that price will rise and fill the gap.

How likely is it that a gap will be filled in a reasonable time period? Use technical indicators to make this determination. If there is an up gap, for example, and price moves fairly close to resistance and/or the RSI shows an overbought reading, the odds of gap filling are in your favor. It might take longer than you are comfortable with, however. This has a bearing when traders are using options which have a time decay factor that lowers their prices each day as you wait for the filling to occur. Similarly, if a gap down occurs, moving price close to support and/or the RSI is at oversold readings, the likelihood of filling the gap are fairly good. As always, identify either bullish or bearish divergences improves the odds of your being correct even more.

When I originally planned to write this blog, another pattern existed that has now ended. The most likely support for the NASDAQ at present is its 50-day moving average. If a gap emerges that is not very far from the 50-day, and the RSI is at or near an overbought reading, the odds that the gap will be filled as part of a retest of support (at the 50-day moving average) are very favorable.

Let me end this post by transcending exclusive reliance on technical criteria. If you are attempting to determine where price will eventually go, create a price forecast using economic criteria. Identify the primary explanatory variables that will influence price over your time period of interest, then predict what each of them will do. Once you have done this, determine the dominant changes and along with that, your price forecast. For the market as a whole, price depends on interest rates and profit expectations. You then find several variables for each of those factors. At the firm or industry level, the choice of factors can differ. For example, interest rates might not be very influential (ex: consumer staples), or how cyclical the firm or its industry are must be accounted for. That leads to your identifying additional factors to use in your forecast.

Hopefully, it might have crossed your mind that it is also highly useful to incorporate intermarket relationships into this type of analysis. What is the commodity market signaling? How about currencies? The bond market? Put all of this together (as you must for the course paper) and you have a very educated guess about the overall market's direction.

Does This Rally Have Legs?

Friday, after a horrible employment report, the market actually rose significantly. Is the market discounting that the worst is now behind us? Or, did the terrible jobs report signal the necessity of both bailing out the "Big 3" automakers and that President-Elect Obama will have to provide an extremely large stimulus package? I think it is far more the latter. Here is a ShortView by John Authers of the Financial Times discussing the current state of the markets.

How far will the market go? In the short-term, you should always check to see where resistance is. In the chart below of the Dow-Jones average (click to enlarge), note the market ended the day just at its 50-day moving average. More importantly, it is instructive to check the Fibonacci Retracement tool I discussed in class just before Thanksgiving. This is included in the graph.

To add a Fibonacci Retracement, go to the Annotation screen (click below the image to get this). When the Java window appears, click on the Fibonacci Tool as shown in the upper portion of the graph.

Holding the left mouse key down, drag the mouse sideways and down:
(1) From the most recent significant high, to
(2) The most recent low. Once there, release the mouse key.

Note how the most likely place for a resistance point, the 38.2% retracement (the first line) is essentially where the market is now approaching. Is it likely that the Dow-Jones will reach this? Check the RSI. It is above 50 (indicating the beginning of a possible uptrend) and it is not close to being overbought. So the potential is clearly there. Also, check to see if there are any major economic statistics this week that if bad could derail this uptrend. There is nothing on the horizon like the employment report of last Friday. So, it is reasonable for the market to move past its 50-day moving average and test the 38.2% retracement at 9,164.

There may well be a "Santa Claus" rally as this year comes to an end, as the bailout (part 1) and promise of an extensive stimulus package will act like the "rumor" in the old saying buy on the rumor, sell on the news. So, early next year, there may well be some kind of correction. But, the relevant question is from what level will this correction occur? We'll have to wait until next semester.