Financial Sector Plunges on Goldman News

On Friday, news about the SEC bringing charges against Goldman Sachs and one of its VP's for fraud charges shook the markets. According to the SEC, Goldman created Collateralized Debt Obligations (CDOs), a collection of parts of mortgage backed bonds, which were destined to fail, then sold them to entities without fully disclosing the facts concerning how these were constructed (toxic) and that a major hedge fund (of Paulson) was betting against them. Here is a link to a story about this. And, in an amazing intermarket application of all of this, there is a potential basis to associate the difficulties with Goldman Sachs with future gold prices. Here is a story about this.

Technical analysis of the ETF for financials (XLF) shows how significant Friday's events were. The chart (click to enlarge) shows how the sharp decline in price on Friday broke a very steep trendline, while still preserving (for now at least) the overall uptrend (based on RSI >= 40). This decline did not lack conviction (sorry for the pun), as it was based on extremely high volume.

Based on Fibonacci Analysis, the next potential support for XLF occurs at the 38.2% retracement  level with a price of $15.77 (Friday's close was $16.36). On the chart, note that the 50% retracement occurs at a prior high (from early January of this year) of $15.35. At this point, a 50% retracement can not be ruled out, as more news will no doubt emerge next week, much of which will involve negatives for Goldman Sachs and (potentially) other similar firms as well. Also, markets tend to overreact in the short-term to such momentous news events.

The question now becomes how financials react and whether this trend for XLF is broken convincingly. For extra credit due at the beginning of class next Tuesday, create a PerfChart of the S&P sectors (as I did in class on Thursday) with a time period that starts at the beginning of April this year. Based on this, which sector has led this "leg" of the rally? What does the chart above signify about any potential changes in what the PerfChart shows? Should the defensive sectors see money flowing in as the result of Friday's news? Paste the PerfChart and brief answers to these questions in a Word document.

One way to assess how financials will do in the near term is to perform technical analysis on the overall stock market. Prior to Friday, the S&P 500 was very overbought, as the RSI(9) was well above 70. After Friday, the RSI fell to below 70, so it is no longer overbought. I also recommend that you look at the economic "numbers" that will be coming out this week. Other than the Leading Economic Indicators on Monday, the only major number with market moving potential is Durable Goods, which is released next Friday morning. So, for much of this week, the market overall and financials in particular will be driven by further news concerning the SEC's case against Goldman Sachs.

Follow Up to January Employment Report

I hate to say I told you so (in the previous post), but the market sold off sharply yesterday (Tuesday, 2/10) when Treasury Secretary Geithner presented his plan (actually, more of a broad outline). Who was particularly hard hit? Banking and financial stocks. What the stock market did yesterday is what it would normally have done on Friday after the employment report. Note that this large market decline occurred along with a very large volume -- indicating "conviction" in this move.

Sadly, this was fairly predictable, not only based on a "buy on the rumor, sell on the news" basis, but since so many of the "talking heads" on television had been trying to convince people that this was an excellent time to get back into the market. I have even heard speculation that had (and when) sufficient details been provided for the financial package the market would rebound. Only if the package ends disease, brings peace to the world, extends global life expectancy to 100+ years! In other words, any package will be imperfect, and market participants will find reasons to be less than enthusiastic.

There are two things I want you to focus on from yesterday. First, we witnessed a textbook example of a flight to safety (review this in the Supply and Demand notes), where persons fled stocks, lowering stock prices, and moved their money to a more safe place, the fixed income (bond) market, raising bond prices and causing interest rates to fall. In fact, the US 10-year bond fell significantly, by about 16 bp yesterday. Second, the Dow-Jones average broke well below 8,000, closing at 7,888. This moves us back to levels we haven't witnessed since mid-November. Don't expect any significant positive market momentum until we get some meaningful clarity on the financial program. In other words, I believe the market will move lower before rising -- we will test further support.

How far might the market fall? Let's rephrase that: where is the next level of support for the Dow-Jones? First, check where price is relative to the 50-day moving average. We failed yet again to break the 50-day, which has to be viewed as short-term resistance at this point. Also, the RSI does not indicate an overbought condition (<30).

Look at the ten-year bond ($TNX) and see how it reacted yesterday. After peaking at 3.05% a few days ago, which had an overbought reading from the RSI, that rate has fallen sharply, yesterday and today (thus far). Also, there was a gap down yesterday. Try identifying relevant economic factors that determine the behavior of the ten-year, determine how those factors will likely be changing, then make a prediction of how the ten-year rate will be moving over the next few days.

After "The" Employment Report

As you know from class, the September employment change was essentially in line with expectations. Payroll employment for the prior two months (July and August) was also revised significantly higher. Most notably, the original employment change for August, a 4,000 decline, was erased. The revised August employment number is an increase of 89,000. Along with this, the unemployment rate rose slightly to 4.7%, and average hourly earnings rose by a greater-than-expected 0.4%.

Hopefully, you took the time to perform the practice exercise in advance of this report. The markets viewed this as a strong employment report. The perceived (key word!) likelihood of a recession dropped noticeably as the result of today's data.

- The stock market liked the report a great deal. It was not too high as to preclude further Fed rate cuts, but not so low that it might have indicated we were in the early stages of a recession. Read a story about this.
- The bond market didn't like this at all -- both significant employment gains and the "hotter" than expected wage gain raised the inflation flag. Here is a story about this. Examine the yield curve to see how the bond market ultimately reacted. Clearly, the yield curve got steeper, indicating the expectation of stronger upcoming growth and inflation.
- The oddity today was the foreign exchange market. Normally, we would assume that the greater perceived economic growth and higher interest rates would both strengthen the US Dollar. However, by day's end, the dollar had weakened further. Read about this. It might have been profit taking by currency traders and the overall perception that the direction for the US dollar is still down. Where is the bounce (support)?

Following what I did in yesterday's posting, I revisited the Market Carpet at StockCharts.com. This time, I looked at the most recent 10 days (not the entire time since the Fed rate cut). The "carpet" below is what pertains (click to enlarge):
Now look at the sectors that have performed the best over the period of this carpet, the last 10 days. All (no exceptions) are cyclically sensitive sectors (look at the bottom right). The leader is Financials. This sector had taken a beating after the financial worries in August. But, with recent data showing that the commercial paper market is improving and possibly stabilizing, there was some "make-up" momentum. Generally, however, it is desirable to see both the Financial and Consumer Discretionary sectors outperforming other sectors.
So, over the past 10 days, the equity market has signaled expectations for an improving level of economic activity. None of these sectors would have performed so well had there been substantial recession concerns. For extra credit (due at the beginning of class on Wednesday), replicate this market carpet (look at yesterday's post for how to do this) but for the 14 days since the last rate cut. Print out the carpet and bring it to class.

Finally, look at the sectors that underperformed: Utilities; Health Care; and Consumer Staples. All of these are defensive sectors, that outperform when recession worries accelerate, but underperform when recession fears abate, as has been the case recently.