August Employment Report

The August employment report came in with a bang. While the consensus prediction for payroll employment was around +110,000 (I had figured around +50,000), the figure released by the Bureau of Labor Statistics was -4,000 -- the first month-to-month decline in four years. Ouch!! You can read about the report.

As I stated in class, this would clearly be one of those "other things are not equal" situations. On the one hand, a weak employment report further fuels the expectation that the Fed will lower rates at its next meeting on 9/18, possibly by 50 basis points (1/2 of a percentage point). That is a positive for the stock market (which is driven primarily by profit expectations and interest rates).
But, weak employment signals less spendable income in future months, which will cut into profits, a negative for stocks. Which effect would dominate? As the morning unfolded it became readily apparent that the negative aspects were more than offsetting the positive factors.

But how could this be? If the Fed will be lowering interest rates soon, and the unemployment remained unchanged, why so negative a reaction by the markets? That's where it is necessary to read the details of the report. First, let me state a rule for judging reports: NEVER PLACE TOO MUCH WEIGHT ON A SINGLE MONTH'S VALUE. Actually the markets didn't. As it turned out, the employment totals for the prior two months were revised sharply lower. This brings me to a second rule: ALWAYS LOOK AT REVISIONS TO PRIOR TIME PERIODS BEFORE JUDGING THE CURRENT VALUE. So, instead of having an average monthly employment gain of around 110,000 over the past three months, the average (with revisions) becomes only +44,000. In addition to this, a further examination of the unemployment rate is called for. While the unemployment rate remained unchanged at 4.6%, the labor force dropped sharply. Had the labor force participation rate (% of population in the labor force) remained the same as it was last month, August's unemployment would have surged to 5%. Now it should become more apparent why the negative reaction occurred.

It is important to keep in mind that the primary factor determining whether a recession is upcoming is whether housing weakness is "contained." The dominant view has been that as long as employment remains strong and the unemployment rate doesn't rise too much, persons should generally be able to afford their mortgages, limiting housing damage. Well, in August, employment fell and the unemployment rate should have risen (with the same participation rate as last month). So, it is not clear how much "containment" will exist going forward, raising the likelihood of a recession (my estimate this entire year has been 45%, well above the consensus until very recently). Add to this the fact that a very large number of mortgages will be "resetting" to higher interest rates in October, and you can see the basis for the stock market selloff. Here's an article highlighting whether a recession is likely.

While we haven't covered it yet, another big reaction to the weak employment report was a sharp drop in interest rates. The 10-year government bond, which is linked to mortgage rates, fell from 4.50% to 4.37%, a 13 basis point drop in one day!! Bonds are fixed (nominal) income assets, meaning they pay fixed amounts of income per year. "Bad news" about the economy, like this employment report, is good news to the bond market as it implies less of an inflation threat in the future (inflation lowers nominal income). And, we will see (later this coming week) that bond prices and interest rates move in opposite directions. So, on Friday we had a stock market sell off and a bond market rally!! Finally, not unrelated to all of this was a sharp rise in gold prices. See if you can figure out gold prices rose. (Hint: it is related to interest rate changes.)

All of this should demonstrate the point I made the first day of class: if you understand macroeconomics you tend to think in terms of sequences (sets) of variable changes, not just what is happening to a single variable. The ability to do this takes practice. Judging by the way this semester has started, you'll be getting lots of practice!

Dow Jones Record

The Dow-Jones Industrial Average ($INDU) set a new record today, closing at its highest level ever. You can read about today's performance or explore its history. The real question is whether this upward move has "legs." Will resistance hold, and today be part of a failed breakout, or will we move toward even higher levels?

Applying technical analysis, there is reason to think that today's record will be met with a pullback in the near term, even though the RSI doesn't indicate that $INDU is oversold (based on the weekly data used). The chart below (click to enlarge) illustrates that the record -- as resistance from early 2000 -- was broken today. Why do I think some pullback is coming? Using the RSI, there is a bearish divergence: the $INDU has moved higher (it has higher highs) but this has not been confirmed by the RSI (it has lower highs).

Where will the Dow-Jones go from here? To answer that question, economics is needed (see the prior post for an example of this).

stock prices = f(expected profit, interest rates)

Put these together and you get the present discounted value of expected future profits. Here are the types of questions that must be answered to arrive at an answer (which, bye the way, is a forecast):

(1) Has the Fed finished raising interest rates?
Will they actually lower rates next year (as the bond market presumes), or will inflation remain in the problematic range?
(2) Today, oil prices fell below $59/barrel. Will this continue? If so, this will moderate inflationary expectations and the inflation premium in nominal interest rates). What about declining gasoline prices? This will help consumers, but with a lag (it takes time to replenish the spending power lost over all these months with $3+ gasoline prices.
(3) How much damage to economic growth will be done by housing sector weakness? Have declining interest rates placed a bottom on the decline in housing, or is there quite a ways (down) to go yet? Look at a few home builder stocks. These appear to have bottomed. Is that a leading indicator of what is to come for the housing sector? Business construction (in the GDP accounts) have begun to rise. Will this be able to offset home construction weakness?
(4) Consumer debt has piled up -- largely through the use of home equity. What will power spending in the next several quarters if home equity can't? Job growth and income gains are critical here.
(5) Will business spending (Equipment and Software) be able to pick up the slack from weaker growth (or actual declines) in consumer spending? Judging from the most recent quarter's GDP report, no. But was the decline in this category an anomaly?
(6) Will growth in Europe continue to pick up and that of Asia remain strong? If so, this bodes well for export growth and profits to firms that have international sales.

This is not necessarily the entire list. But for a forecast of stock prices, like any forecast, you must identify what the relevant factors will be in the next 6 months or year, predict what each of these will do, then put all of this together to arrive at a conclusion.

Bond Market

Today we discussed the bond market in class and how bond prices and interest rates move in opposite directions. This can be seen vividly in today's news. Existing (median) home prices declined relative to last year, a rare event. This is bullish for bonds since it implies that inflation should come down a bit, and the inflation measures we use (like the CPI) will likely drop as well. Remember: bullish for the bond market means higher demand and higher bond prices -- which causes lower interest rates. You can read about this in an article from MarketWatch.com.

To further understand what is happening, remember our basic model of nominal interest rates (r):

r = f(expected inflation, economic growth, monetary policy)

Today, the news caused expected inflation (and actually expected growth) to moderate, causing nominal interest rates to fall. Remember: you can also explore this by using the ratio TIP:TLT in StockCharts.com, or take a look at the TIPS spread from Bloomberg.com (the link is: http://www.bloomberg.com/markets/rates/index.html ). You should bookmark this link.

When at Bloomberg.com above, page down to the graph. This is today's yield curve. Then, click on the tabs for different countries. Compare the interest rates (say 10 year) for the different countries listed.

Finally, oil prices bounced off support at $60 today. Graph $WTIC in StockCharts.com. Look to the left from today's values to see where support lies. You will see a $60 support point from early March of this year. Had this support not held, the prior support of just under $58 that I mentionned in class would be the relevant level. There was a bullish divergence in effect which makes today's move not entirely surprising. Oil price was falling while the RSI was making higher lows.

The question now is how long this upward move will hold. How far might it go? Resistance, remember?